Why Calorie Calculators DON’T Work
How accurate are activity trackers, really?
According to researchers at Stanford University, most fitness trackers can’t be relied on to accurately track number of calories burned. Here’s what happened:
Apple Watch, Basis Peak, Fitbit Surge, Microsoft Band, Mio Alpha 2, PulseOn and Samsung Gear S2 were tested in a group of 60 people. The results showed that measuring heart rate had an error rate of less than 5% on 6 of the devices, while none of the devices were accurate when measuring energy expenditure. The most accurate device was incorrect by 27% on average while the least accurate was off by 93%.
Thirty-one women and 29 men volunteered to help test the accuracy of the devices. Each volunteer wore the 7 devices while walking or running on treadmills or while using stationary bikes. Their heart rates were measured using a medical-grade electrocardiograph and the metabolic rate was measured with an instrument that measured the oxygen and carbon dioxide in their breath. The researchers then compared the results from the actual medical devices to the fitness trackers.
“The heart rate measurements performed far better than we expected,” said Ashley. “But the energy expenditure measures were way off the mark. The magnitude of just how bad they were surprised me.”
Since each device uses its own custom algorithm for calculating energy expenditure, the researchers aren’t sure why the measurements are so wrong.
“All we can do is see how the devices perform against the gold-standard clinical measures,” Shcherbina said. “My take on this is that it’s very hard to train an algorithm that would be accurate across a wide variety of people because energy expenditure is variable based on someone’s fitness level, height and weight, etc.”
And that’s why any activity tracker that claims to tell you “resting calorie burn” or “metabolic rate” is just plain wrong. Luckily, Breezing’s Calorie Corrector is here to correct the numbers generated by activity trackers, bridging the gap between activity trackers’ estimates and true metabolic rate.
For more details on the Stanford study, follow this link: http://www.medicaldesignandoutsourcing.com/fitness-tracker-misleading-data/
MyFitnessPal, Striiv Play, and Breezing Metabolism Tracking
Breezing’s study has just been published by the Global Journal of Obesity, Diabetes and Metabolic Syndrome. Our study, “Study of the Effect of Mobile Indirect Calorimeter on Weight Management” takes a closer look at calorie-counting, step-counting, and REE-counting.
To see the results, click here
Breezing Metabolism Tracker and Pregnancy: Published in Global Journal
Breezing has been featured in a new study published by the Global Journal of Obesity, Diabetes and Metabolic Syndrome.
In this study, researchers took a closer look at the question: how does metabolism tracking affect weight change during and after pregnancy?
To read the study, click here
Breezing Nominated as Finalist in “Best of Baby Tech!”
Breezing has long been a favorite of weight practitioners, dietitians, and obesity doctors all over the world, but expecting mothers have been the newest group of users to adopt Breezing into their lives.
For that reason, Breezing was recently selected as a Finalist in the “Best of Baby Tech” Awards 2016.
The folks at Baby Tech Awards found the Breezing Tracker and App approachable, user friendly, and critically important, making a real impact for the healthy development of babies during pregnancy. We’ll be featured with the other Baby Tech Finalists at CES 2017! As an early adopter of the Breezing Technology, we’re asking you to help spread the word!
Vote for us here!
Breezing Featured in “Today’s Dietician”
New article in Today’s Dietician! Read it here: http://www.todaysdietitian.com/industry_news.shtml
Metabolism during Pregnancy: What Happens?
Metabolism changes greatly during pregnancy, and the way it changes can be different for each woman. Despite an increased need for calories, excessive gestational weight gain still affects many women, contributing to adverse maternal and child health outcomes. Extensive research has shown that real-time tracking of health parameters may improve prenatal health.
To better understand how pregnancy and metabolism are related, the Breezing Metabolism Team is working with The Human Placenta Project, a collaborative research effort launched by the NICHD to study the role of the placenta in health and disease.
(The.pdf version of this presentation is available for download here.)
Looking at three pregnancy cases, the results showed that REE during pregnancy can increase, stay the same, or even decrease. In the first case, REE increased during the second trimester and remained relatively stable through delivery. In the second case, REE stayed the same throughout pregnancy. In the third case, REE decreased with nausea and remained low later in pregnancy.
These results show that REE is unique for each woman, and it is a complex variable that depends on a number of different factors. “Calculating” REE is no different from estimating it. And, as studies have shown, these estimates can be very wrong. When considering the health of both the mother and the child, it’s more important than ever to measure and track metabolism, not just “calculate” a number.
Success Story: Dennis
We love to hear about the experiences of our Breezing users. This is Dennis’s inspiring success story, in his own words.
“My name is Dennis Bell. I am 67 years old in excellent physical condition and health but not too many years ago I couldn’t say that.
I remember returning to my hometown of Knoxville Tennessee over 4 years ago after spending almost 3 years in Washington State on my last consulting engineer assignment before retiring at age 62. Although I was elated to return to my hometown, I had let my weight get out of hand. I weighed 289 lbs.
The Weight Loss Plateau: Meet Fred
Feeling stuck on a weight loss plateau? You’re not alone. Based on true user stories, here’s why conventional exercise and dieting routines don’t work.
It’s all about your metabolism.